The other person is, of course, exposed and expressive in other ways than through the literal face e. Professor castleberrys philosophical lecture shorts. Michael eldred believes that levinas throws the baby out with the bathwater. I knew that my voice would tremble at the moment of saying it, and especially saying it aloud, right here, before him, so close to him, pronouncing this word of adieu, this word adieu, which, in a certain sense, i get from him, a word that he will have taught me to think or to pro nounce otherwise.
The face of the other and the trace of god contain essays on the philosophy of emmanuel levinas, and how his philosophy intersects with that of other. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The last two essays in humanism of the other also appeared in the collected philosophical papers translated by al lingis, and are remarkable primarily for articulating levinas response to the largely french debates over humanism and culture during the 1960s. Jeko ogheneochuko victor emmanuel levinas s ethics of the face to face relation. Emmanuel levinasethics and infinity flashcards quizlet. Pdf the relation with the other, or conversation, is a nonallergic relation, an ethical relation. As such, the face of the other is verticality and uprightness. For levinas, the subject cannot reject the moral urge of the other since the urge. The face of the other is a disturbance, it leaves effects.
Conclusion of the summary on totality and infinity. Levinas writes, and he invites us to accompany him for this unique journey, opening the eyes, discovering an oddly familiar figure, coming face to face and finally initiating a rapport with this other. However, this essay will argue that his attempts to instantiate an. The face is present in its refusal to be contained. To that end, i imagine an encounter between two very different others. This chapter presents levinas s ethical philosophy, or his humanism of the other, as a rejection of any postmodern antihumanisms, and as the conscious effort to counteract heideggers definition of human dignity as the shepherd of being. Pdf whats inside levinas, the face and the kalooban. Totality and infinity 206 the face, preeminently expression, formulates the first word. An imperative for dialogical philosophy nnamdi azikiwe university, awka, nigeria 2012 p. Theory excludes the implantation of the knowing being in the known being, the entering into the beyond by ecstasy. For emmanuel levinas, the stranger is one of the most visible faces of. It is neither seen nor touchedfor in visual or tactile sensation the identity of the i envelops the alterity of the object, which becomes precisely a content. Levinas work had a major impact on derrida and poststructuralist and existentialist theorists who followed.
As richard cohen notes, for levinas,the human first emerges in the face to face cohen 1994, 124. We can consider that the phenomenology of levinas is operating face of the other man as the heart of his work. When questioned, levinas explicitly says that the ethical com. Other face to face, consist in and what is its purpose.
In that, the obligation of the other in the face of the. Face to face with levinas makes available to american readers the best of recent thought on emmanuel levinas. It is thus the personal other, the other person, whoever it is, that each of us encounters directly or experiences the traces of every day. Levinas explains that the face of the other talking to yourself. For levinas, the irreducible relation, the epiphany, of the facetoface, the encounter with another, is a privileged phenomenon in which the other persons proximity and distance are both strongly felt. The presence of the other does not contradict the freedom of self.
Mar 09, 2007 the face of the other is a phrase used by emmanuel levinas, an important twentiethcentury philosopher who has won my deep interest and admiration. This is a short video i made to help my students understand emmanuel levinas s concept of otherness as it applies to media studies. Pdf this is a study of the way in which levinas approaches the experience of human. It means that, ethically, people are responsible to oneanother in the facetoface encounter. It is believing that love without reward is valuable. The face of the other is the exteriority of his being. Before going further, we must deal with a familiar objection to the thought that levinas should be situated within the context of phenomenological idealism.
Levinas and the face of the other chapter 3 the cambridge. Sep 21, 2016 for levinas, the face of the other is an expression of pure vulnerability together with an ethical command to protect it. My claims are, that it is an incontrovertible fact that levinas philosophy is based upon husserlian philosophy, but also, that. Professor castleberry gives a lecture on the 20th century continental philosopher emmanuel levinas and his thinking surrounding the face of the other. Face to face is an ethical relationship, and calls the freedom of self responsibility. Though levinass thought has some affinities with martin bubers, the relation with the other as levinas describes it is to be distinguished from bubers ithou. Given the very nature of levinass thought, involving an infinite responsibility for the other and an equally infinite interpretability of. In other words, the ego can never totally know the other. Start studying emmanuel levinas ethics and infinity. His main contribution to philosophy is the ethics of the face which focuses on the relation of the self to the other human person.
The levinas reader has both used the best of several extant english language versions of his work, and commissioned translations especially for this volume. Levinas takes the face to face relationship between each subject and every other particular person to be a relationship of the self with transcendence. Chapter four brings us to a more evident link between ethics and religion in levinass thought, namely, to the discussion of the face of the other as a trace of the. Language begins with the presence of the face with the expression. Thereafter, levinas must contend with the implications of his own writing his thematization and rhetoric, which includes his claims for the face. Levinas expresses a interesting perspective on the problem of modern alienation in that it explains. It is therefore to receive from the other beyond the capacity of the i, which means. Emmanuel levinas came from an orthodox lithuanian background but left for france in the 1930 to study with edmund husserl and martin heidegger in germany. Notes to emmanuel levinas stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Subordinate to the other, i am always ethically responsible for the other in an. I shall suggest that levinas receives but transforms these structures to bestow on them an ethical import missing in simmels purely aesthetic descriptions.
Accor ding to levinas, the facetoface r elationship with the other person, the other, is beyond the grasp of ontology. Emmanuel levinas 19051995 intellectual project was to develop a first philosophy. While levinas famously claims that ethics precedes ontology and emanates from the concrete experience of the other s face, it is often forgotten that deleuze also discusses the face in numerous. Levinas on god and the trace of the other oxford handbooks. Reprinted from dialogue with emmanuel levinas, in face to face with levinas, edited by richard a. The being that presents himself in the face comes from a dimension of height, a dimension of transcendence whereby he can present himself as a stranger without opposing me as obstacle or enemy. Although there is no evidence that everett is channeling the philosophy of emmanuel levinas in his novels, this paper will read everetts 1994 novel, gods. Although this braided structure makes the notion of the face an.
Emmanuel levinas quotes author of totality and infinity. Emmanuel levinas, lithuanianborn french philosopher renowned for his powerful critique of the preeminence of ontology the philosophical study of being in the history of western philosophy, particularly in the work of the german philosopher martin heidegger 18891976. Emmanuel levinas my effort consists in showing that knowledge is in reality an immanence, and that there is no rupture of the isolation of being in knowledge. Further, the face of the other reveals to me the injusticeas well as the impossibilityof my claim to sovereign freedom and egoistic enjoyment. Whereas traditionally first philosophy denoted either metaphysics or theology, only to be reconceived by heidegger as fundamental ontology, levinas argued that it is ethics that should be so conceived. From within the phenomenological tradition, levinas grounds the phenomenon of the human subjectivity, dignity, language, desire. Bringing the levinasian other face to face with the postcolonial other in conversation reveals that there is great potential but also some serious obstacles to making levinas s ethics productive for a postcolonial transformation of the violent colonial self other relationship. Specifically, levinas says that the human face orders and ordains us. Thinking on film emmanuel levinas, the trace of the other.
In this muchneeded introduction, davis unpacks the concepts at the center of levinas s thoughtalterity, the other, the face, infinityconcepts which have previously presented readers with major problems of interpretation. Levinas and the face of the other philosophical explorations. In proposing the other as that which is prior to the self, putting demands on us before we can either ignore or help. But rather than formulating an ethical theory, levinas. Ive read other introductions to levinas but none like this one. Nov 14, 20 professor castleberry gives a lecture on the 20th century continental philosopher emmanuel levinas and his thinking surrounding the face of the other. It means that, ethically, people are responsible to oneanother in the face to face encounter.
The schema of theory in which metaphysics was found distinguished theory from all ecstatic behavior. Later, of course, levinas will attribute infinity to a different experience, that of the unbounded quality of the face of the other. Psychotherapy for the other represents the latest and one of the most innovative and indepth attempt to address this intriguing and important question. He believes this dimension of our interpersonal experience is represented in traditional religious and theological texts by the relationship with the divine or god. In the face of the other lies the reflection of our ability to harm them, and an interdiction that prohibits us from ever doing so. He has commented on many strands of the western philosophical tradition, including the thought of plato, descartes, hegel, and heidegger. Notes to emmanuel levinas stanford encyclopedia of. In time he developed his ethical theory of the other for which levinas is famous today. When george kunz, a coeditor of the present volume, visited with emmanuel levinas in 1987, levinas asked, why would a psychologist be interested in my philosophy. The approach to the face is the most basic mode of responsibility.
For levinas, it is the face of the other that addresses us thus and focuses our attention, prior to our considering that face s empirical qualities sex, ethnicity, etc basterra 2015. Chapter four brings us to a more evident link between ethics and religion in levinas s thought, namely, to the discussion of the face of the other. It is possible to approach this question of ethical agency through the issues of the will and intentionality in order to outline how questions of responsibility can guide. I can kill the other, but his face reminds me of my responsibility. Emmanuel levinas stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Transcendence as the idea of infinity the schema of theory in which metaphysics was found distinguished theory from all ecstatic behavior. When such questions were put to him in an interview, recorded as the paradox of morality in the provocation of levinas, levinas says that other animals do. Being neither something real inside, nor something ideal outside the world, the face announces the corporeal absence leibhaftige abwesenheit of the other. Celebration of emmanuel levinas centennial january 1december 31, 2006. Subject formation in relation to responsibility and moral philosophy pertains to the question of what it means to think about the formation of the subject as an ethical subject or, in other words, as an ethical agent.
Emmanuel levinas and the face of the other the following consists of quotations that help illuminate what levinas means by the face of the other. Emmanuel levinas is one of the most important postmodern french philosophers. The face cannot be totalized because it expresses in. It is a must if you want to start understanding the complexities of one of the major thinkers of our time. Faith is not a question of the existence or nonexistence of god. Levinas, simmel, and the ethical significance of money. Responsibility in the face of the other my jewish learning. Ill make two clarifying points and then give some quotations from levinas. It emerges out of being and what levinas feels is the natural conatus essendi. Levinas, phenomenology and the question of responsibility jack reynolds abstract derrida has been rather frequently acclaimed for his conception of alterity, which we are told is irrecuperable and beyond the dialectic. Levinas and the face of the other oxford handbooks. Sep 16, 2017 this is a short video i made to help my students understand emmanuel levinass concept of otherness as it applies to media studies.
This paper explores how levinas s appropriation of the. The ethics of responsibility for the face to face interaction in the virtual world margarita victoria gomez prof. The human face we encounter first of all as the other s face strikes us as a highly ambiguous phenomenon. The face of the other the desire to love and the desire to. It arises here and now without finding its place within the world. While derrida is convinced that his own work avoids the residual humanism that he argues is discernible.
Tracing the genesis of the notion of the face in a series of early writings published between 1947 and 1954, this essay shows that this notion does not develop in a linear fashion but through several distinct lines of argument that are then welded or woven together without being completely unified. Bringing the levinasian other face to face with the postcolonial other in conversation reveals that there is great potential but also some serious obstacles to making levinass ethics productive for a postcolonial. In 1961, levinas defines transcendence strictly in light of the other. It is also worth acknowledging that according to derrida, levinas position partly betrays itself, because the wholly other is absolutely other only if it is human and hence partly the same wd 127. Of course, we encounter a multiplicity of others, but levinas more often uses the singular other to emphasize that we encounter others one at a time, face to face.
Levinas, a work which progressively analyses the alterity of existence in existence and existents. The other is not other with a relative alterity as are, in a. The place and face of the stranger in levinas 2279 mdpi. Meaning is the face of the other, and all recourse to words takes place already within the primordial face to face of language. The face of the other the desire to love and the desire to kill to the significance of emmanuel levinas for gestalttherapy i was surprised yesterday to listen to donna orange, and her love to levinas jumped out of her sentences. In this sense it can not be comprehended, that is, encompassed. This implies that he must grapple with criticism to the effect that he is providing a foundationless hermeneutics of facetoface.
An introduction to levinas emmanuel levinas is considered by many to be one of the most important philosophers of the twentieth century and perhaps of the entire philosophical tradition. Totality and infinity is a profound and challenging work. The face of the other selections from totality and infinity by emmanuel levinas. Other sometimes capitalized, sometimes not usually translates the french word autrui, which means the other person, someone else i. For levinas, the irreducible relation, the epiphany, of the facetoface, the encounter with another, is a privileged phenomenon in which the other persons. Levinas claim that ethics and not ontology deserves to be labeled.
1059 938 474 54 1489 464 997 1104 356 92 1028 1093 896 93 579 322 457 198 909 281 1354 431 702 700 1093 503 1007 550 526 1241 1407 537 688 1022 854 525 68 275 1474 852 239 1221 401 1361 846 936 1383 409 669